Beach Farm

Butlers Cove Road & Forever Wild Way | Edgartown, MA

A rare private compound where refined island living meets the relaxed rhythm of life by the water.

Set waterfront in one of Edgartown’s most coveted settings, Beach Farm is an extraordinary multi-residence compound created for an unforgettable Martha’s Vineyard escape. With multiple beautifully appointed homes, gorgeous water views, expansive outdoor spaces, private sandy coves on Edgartown Great Pond, wellness amenities, stunning sunsets, and access to the Herring Creek Farm Association Beach, Beach Farm offers exceptional privacy, flexibility, and connection to the island’s natural beauty.

At the heart of the compound is the elegant main residence, a sophisticated home designed around effortless indoor/outdoor living. Sun-filled gathering spaces open seamlessly to the surrounding grounds, while multiple fireplaces, private balconies, generous decks, and beautifully appointed interiors create a sense of warmth and comfort throughout the home.

The second floor primary wing is a peaceful retreat unto itself, featuring a king bedroom, gas fireplace, luxurious en-suite bath with double vanity and walk-in shower, and a private balcony. Additional guest suites provide king beds, en-suite baths, private balconies or decks, and outdoor showers, allowing family and friends to enjoy their own private spaces while remaining connected to the larger compound.

The main level is equally well suited to gathering and entertaining. A beautifully appointed kitchen flows into the dining and living areas, creating an inviting central gathering space. The living room features a wet bar and gas fireplace, while a separate den offers another quiet retreat with its own fireplace and stunning views. A mudroom, lounge, laundry room, powder room, and additional flexible spaces provide all the comforts necessary for an extended stay.

Wellness is woven throughout the property. The main house features a sauna, steam shower, soaking tub, and multiple outdoor showers, creating a serene setting to unwind. Outside, guests can enjoy private beach access, gather around the gas fire pit, dine alfresco, and relax on the expansive decks overlooking the water.

*Pool anticipated for spring 2027

A short distance from the main residence, the Surf House offers an additional private retreat. The open kitchen, dining, and living area create an easygoing gathering space, while three king bedrooms provide comfortable private accommodations.

The residence also features three full baths, two outdoor showers, a private sauna, cold plunge, laundry, Sonos, a spacious outdoor deck and a private beach.

The Cottage at Forever Wild Way features a kitchen and living area, full bath, two bedrooms (one with a king bed and one with two twin beds), an outdoor shower, cold plunge, and a viewing tower offering a wonderful vantage point from which to take in the surrounding landscape.

The true magic of Beach Farm is found in its extraordinary connection to the land and water. The property encompasses three private beach parcels on Edgartown Great Pond and access to 1500 feet of association beach on the Atlantic Ocean. This offers guests rare and intimate shoreline access, creating a variety of places to enjoy the water, from quiet morning swims to leisurely afternoons by the sea.

Beyond the beaches, Beach Farm has its own working farm, adding another wonderfully authentic dimension to the experience. Featuring a flourishing flower and vegetable garden, chickens and beehives. Guests can enjoy the simple pleasure of island life at its freshest, with farm-fresh eggs delivered each morning.

Days at Beach Farm unfold naturally between the gardens, beaches, and beautifully appointed residences. Multiple outdoor living and dining areas invite long meals and leisurely afternoons, while the property's outdoor showers, sauna, cold plunges, and other wellness amenities make it easy to embrace the slower pace of island living.

Beach Farm offers something far beyond a traditional vacation rental. It is an immersive Martha’s Vineyard experience, a private estate where the beauty, bounty, and natural rhythm of island life are woven into every day.